A Formless Echoing....
Music Is King

HOME

Essays and Stories
Can I Borrow A Feeling?
If I'm Not Religious, Can A Camera Still Take My Soul?
Artsy Fartsy Stuff
Say You're A Monkey
Music Is King
My Favorite Recordings
Photos from Ghost Hunts and Various Indiana Jones Missions
So You Wanna Bang A Drum?
Where Does George Washington Keep His Armies?
Creatures and Plants I Ingest
Poems and Words
Yvan Eht Nioj
Link Me Up, Before Ya Go Go

One question that I can never ever answer easily is "what kinds of music do you like?"

Well here is the short version. I have managed to acquire several hundred CD's, LP's, and recently, SACD's over the span of my life. To answer most laypeople I would have to actually start lecturing them in musicology. Do I want to appear that boring? Especially when it comes to something so exciting as music?
 
No, I do not wish to sound like a boring academic when it comes to music. But I will anyway, whether I like it or not.
 
 
Our planet has on hand almost 1000 years of written and recorded music. It also has an entire globe's worth of genres, cultures, and materials to produce instruments.
 
I have a hard time dismissing the merits of any style or period of music. This is not to say that I do not have my favorites and I do not have music which makes me sick. My opinions are very very strong only unlike the average person, I have made an effort to expose myself to as much music as possible. I feel this makes my short meaningless existence a little more worthwhile. Some people like to watch other people playing games, and I like to find new music to enjoy. Just a matter of preference.
 
On seperate page I will list from among my favorite discs, the ones which I feel are most deserving of praise. Beware though, because you probably haven't heard of a lot of them. I'll tell a little bit about them.
 
On this page, I will try to honestly keep you abreast of my latest purchases and provide informative reviews based upon them. I may also spout off a bit about SACD vs. DVD-Audio. Oh, and if you consider yourself a true music fan but are unaware of these new formats, you really should smack yourself.
 
For the record, I hope SACD's blow DVD-Audios out of the water.

It's Finally Here! Dark Side of the Moon on SACD!
 
Yep, you heard it right. And yes....I own a copy!
 
So is it as amazing as it should be? In a word, yes. But shouldn't I talk about it at length? I mean after all, that is the purpose of writing reviews. It's an excuse to sound intelligent.
 
I'll start by saying that the price for what you get is just great. In 1993 I recall my first purchase of the Dark Side 20th anniversary release. It was a decent remaster, and sounded great for the time. It cost me about $17. (1993 money no less) It was a two channel PCM transfer.
 
Now in 2003, when the average price of a regular CD is still around $15-$17, getting my hands on a 5.1 channel DSD transfer for $15 is a much bigger bargain. When you also consider that this disc is a hybrid, which will play in any standard CD player as well....it makes no sense to purchase a regular CD of Dark Side anymore. This will no doubt boost the market for SACD; something which I find to be a wonderful development which will no doubt cast a dark shadow over the competing but inferior DVD-Audio format. It is my personal wish that this release will be the first nail on DVD-Audio's coffin.
 
Ok, personal feelings aside....let's talk about this disc. The surround mix is breathtaking. Guthrie has succeeded in making the music truly three-dimensional. Throughout my listening, I often found myself amazed that the original masters are 30 years old. Or maybe the original masters just always sounded that good, only we couldn't hear that until SACD and its DSD encoding. This is as close to hearing the original master tapes as we have ever been able to get at home.
 
Dark Side was originally recorded on a 16 track system, which meant that when the final mixdowns were made into two-tracks for home audio listening, lots of the sound would have to end up muddled together and obscured. Now that the channels can be mixed with five independents, we get to hear every breathtaking nuance of each instrument and voice. You truly experience the album almost for the first time, sometimes hearing things you never knew were there.
 
Even played on the SACD stereo (2 channel) layer, the recording is still breathtaking. The timbre, tone and general feeling with the new DSD transfer is so transparent that one feels like they are listening to the master tapes themselves, even in two channel audio. Pink Floyd is right there in your room, jamming like mad.
 
Guthrie's work has also made the red-book layer (regular CD) better than any previous release. I have the fortune of being able to play both at once and switch back and forth on my amp. There is a great difference between the two; the older disc seems boxed-in, somewhat lower in fidelity. The seperation between the instruments is also a little on the muddy side, whereas the new release has a quality that is more open and airy. Even if you don't have an SACD player yet....I would strongly suggest that you purchase this disc. Not only is it the best release of Dark Side yet....it will also inspire you to purchase an SACD player....and explore a whole new world of music.
 
The only regret I have about this release isn't even about the release itself. Rather it is about the quality of music that exists today. I mean here we are in 2003 with the advent of multichannel high definition music media, and the best thing we have to release on it is....30 years old! Now if that isn't proof that today's music is mostly crap, I don't know what is.
 
Production, content, and execution A+
 
Overall listening pleasure A+
 
 
-The Fish
 
 

To see my most prized sonic possessions...click the link below....

My Favorite Recordings

My latest acquisitions:
 
Review of: Yo-Yo Ma and The Silk Road Ensemble
Silk Road Journeys (When Strangers Meet)
Straight DSD to SACD Multichannel Recording (and it's a darn good one!)

In a world tired from all of the bad New Age attempts at world fusion music, what can master cellist Yo-Yo Ma bring to the table aside from his classic singing tone and artistic integrity?

Well, something new and unique; something refreshing and most certainly worth a look.

Ma formed the Silk Road Ensemble in the late 1990s for the purpose of exploring the exciting possibilities he envisioned when blending instrumentations and traditions found in the areas that lined the old Silk Road, but in a modern sensibility.

 Attempts to fuse musical styles in a modern setting have been deeply contrasting over the years. Sometimes hit, and sometimes miss. The hits have been spectacular, as in Paul Simon's 1986 landmark LP Graceland. But the misses...well in fairness I wont call out names. But I will mention some genres where attempts at world fusion have been mediocre at best. Some New Age music is just for the birds. Some supposed world electronica (with all due respect to Transglobal Underground and Thievery Corporation) has been just bloody awful.

 My respect for the fusion of world sounds in a popular setting was made solid by the efforts of Paul Simon, Peter Gabriel, and Jimmy Page and Robert Plant's UnLedded tours. But what about the fusion of world music with...well...world music?

 Enter Yo-Yo Ma. America's favorite classical cellist comes through with a new folk fusion sound with roots running deep in well-established traditions spanning cultures from across a vast geographical area as well as a long-standing history. This is a dangerous, even daunting task when you think about it. The chances for failure here are greater than in the simpler world of pop music. The audience is more critical, more knowledgeable. The pieces are more complex, the instruments less familiar. The people playing together have never met.

 But this is the very edge Ma has turned to his advantage. The title of the album, When Strangers Meet says it all. Here is the capturing of the Silk Road itself; that ancient place between worlds where East met West and strange tongues sought to communicate through trade.

 And it can be certain they didn't just trade goods. They traded glances. They traded methods of art, science, and music. Here is the quintessence of this recording; its use of music as a language of communications. We see through the eyes of the musicians, and we see them looking straight into each others souls.

 This recording also finds our favorite cellist in unfamiliar territory.a place that classical musicians dread. Improvisation! And he shines out. He is amazing. He even attempts to play unfamiliar cello-like instruments. And I will say that after only a few days of practice, the man can really hold his own. Ever reinventing himself, I will always look forward to Yo-Yo's recordings.

 Okay, enough flowery talk. What about the product?

 The product is rock solid. Period. Haunting compositions and spirited improvisations. There is a sense of adventure here as well as a sense of grounding in these deep traditions. The musicians are master musicians of their craft and this is paramount in understanding the difference between the popular music we are used to and how it contrasts the traditions of music to be found in the non drive-thru cultures.

For us, some guy playing a few chords in his mom's basement can be called music. Our folk tradition is in general just a suburban teen playing a Squier Stratocaster on an old amp one day and being a rock star the next. And hey, there is nothing at all wrong with this in my mind. I love rock and roll...its the shit. But, in order to truly understand the absolute power of music we must take a moment to learn what music is to someone in this ensemble.

 These are people who were born to their instruments. They have dwelled in the culture of these instruments. Their grandparents mastered them. Their great-grandparents mastered them. They are instruments and traditions of an entire people and they are symbols of the very cultures from which they come. Every note played by one of these people is a note from an eternal source; a testament to the survival of their way of life and the pride they feel in their heritage. They are playing for their history, for their country, for their village...for their people. Creating a simple jam session with these master musicians is a radically different endeavor than you might imagine.

 This is not to say that the recording isnt fun. Its as playful as anything, and the rendition of an old medieval Italian street song (Chi passa per'sta strada) is a joy to listen to. This track is also the best example of the DSD Multichannel recording technology of the SACD. Each percussion instrument finds a home in a different speaker, wrapping itself around the listener nicely, but also providing us with an ultimate argument against the surround music nay-sayers; the seperation of the channels allows us to hear more seperation between the instruments, making the tones ring clearer and more transparently. In laymans terms, it sounds more realistic.

 Well, all in all I would say this recording is flawless. BUT.

 Some of the compositions and tones, to be truly frank with you, are simply not appealing to my ears. This is only my opinion, so it goes off the record. But I will say that the opening track is quite annoying. Its a traditional female singer from Mongolia. I take it I will not like any Mongolian female vocal music, because it sounds like dead cats being scolded by a washerwoman. I have tried repeatedly to listen to it, honestly trying to learn how to like it. But I simply can't. It just sounds horrid.

 Some of the compositions can also be rather lengthy at times. But this is the nature of Eastern music. It is really my Western ears and their limitations that stop me from the full appreciation of this debut effort by an ensemble with a promising future. I will say that I expect the next recording to be a little more flowing, owing to the nature of musicians and their need to feel each other out, but this disc is excellent and worth checking out.

 Production, content and execution - A+

Overall Listening pleasure - C+

 

- The Fish

Enter supporting content here